Comparison of Strategy Models
Strategy Guide
Discover how the Emergent Approach reshapes strategy, challenges traditional models, and empowers organisations to thrive in dynamic business landscapes.
Overview
Introduction
In the realm of strategic management, various models guide organisations in navigating complex business environments.
Peter Compo’s Emergent Approach to Strategy offers a dynamic perspective, contrasting with traditional models that often emphasise deliberate planning and predictable outcomes.
This guide provides a comparative analysis of the Emergent Approach alongside other prominent strategic models, highlighting their core principles, advantages, and limitations.
Want to Read More About Change Management?
Table of Contents
In this guide you will learn about:
Traditional Strategic Models
Deliberate Strategy
Popularised by scholars like Michael Porter, deliberate strategy involves meticulous planning and execution. Organisations set specific goals and develop detailed plans to achieve them, assuming a stable environment.
This approach focuses on establishing competitive advantages through cost leadership, differentiation, or focus strategies.
Advantages:
- Clear Direction: Provides a defined path for the organisation.
- Resource Allocation: Facilitates efficient distribution of resources.
Performance - Measurement: Enables straightforward assessment of progress against set objectives.
Limitations:
- Rigidity: May not adapt well to unforeseen changes.
Assumption of - Predictability: Relies on the premise that the business environment is stable and predictable.
- Slow Response: Can be sluggish in reacting to emerging opportunities or threats.
Prescriptive Strategy
Prescriptive strategies involve detailed planning and analysis before implementation. They are based on the belief that the future can be predicted and controlled through comprehensive planning.
Advantages:
- Comprehensive Analysis: Encourages thorough understanding of the market and internal capabilities.
- Risk Mitigation: Aims to foresee and plan for potential challenges.
Limitations:
- Time-Consuming: The extensive planning process can delay action.
- Inflexibility: May not accommodate rapid changes in the environment.
The Emergent Approach to Strategy
Contrasting with traditional models, the Emergent Approach, as articulated by Henry Mintzberg and further developed by Peter Compo, posits that strategy should evolve in response to real-time changes and learning within the organisation.
This approach recognises that the business environment is complex and unpredictable, necessitating flexibility and adaptability.
Advantages:
- Adaptability: Allows organisations to respond swiftly to unforeseen opportunities and threats.
- Continuous Learning: Encourages ongoing assessment and refinement of strategies.
- Employee Engagement: Involves various organisational levels in the strategic process, fostering a sense of ownership.
Limitations:
- Lack of Clear Direction: May lead to ambiguity if not properly managed.
Resource Allocation - Challenges: Continuous changes can complicate efficient resource distribution.
Potential for - Inconsistency: Frequent shifts in strategy might confuse stakeholders.
Comparative Analysis
| Aspect | Deliberate Strategy | Emergent Approach |
|---|---|---|
| Planning Process | Structured and formalised with clear objectives. | Flexible and evolving based on real-time information. |
| Decision-Making | Top-down, centralised authority. | Inclusive, involving multiple organisational levels. |
| Adaptability | Limited, due to rigid plans. | High, allows for quick responses to change. |
| Risk Management | Focuses on identifying and mitigating known risks. | Embraces uncertainty, viewing it as a source of opportunity. |
| Resource Allocation | Pre-determined based on strategic plans. | Dynamic, resources are allocated as needs emerge. |
| Performance Metrics | Based on achieving set objectives and milestones. | Evaluated through continuous feedback and learning. |
Integrating Deliberate and Emergent Strategies
Implementation Tips:
Set Clear Objectives
Establish overarching goals to provide direction
Encourage Flexibility
Allow teams the autonomy to adapt tactics as situations evolve
Foster a Learning Culture
Promote continuous feedback and knowledge sharing
Regularly Review Strategies
Assess and adjust strategies in response to new information and environmental changes
Conclusion
The choice between deliberate and emergent strategies is not binary. Organisations should assess their specific contexts, industries, and internal capabilities to determine the most suitable approach.
By understanding and potentially integrating both models, businesses can navigate the complexities of today’s dynamic environments more effectively.
For a deeper exploration of the Emergent Approach to Strategy, Peter Compo’s work provides valuable insights. You can explore further at Emergent Approach and StratNavApp.com.
Further Resources
Useful Links
StratNavApp is The Sixsess Consultancy’s preferred and recommended tool for strategic and organisation planning.
The Sixsess Consultancy
Our bespoke consultancy services are designed to empower leaders, optimise processes, and embed sustainable change.
Contact us today to learn more about how we can support your journey.
About The Sixsess Consultancy
Experts in Change and Transformation
The Sixsess Consultancy specialises in guiding organisations through complex transformations. Our bespoke consultancy services are designed to empower leaders, optimise processes, and embed sustainable change. With proven strategies and a team-first approach, we help organisations navigate change with confidence.
Ready to transform your organisation? Contact us today to learn more about how we can support your journey.
